Understanding Oil Canning in Metal Panels: What It Is and How to Minimize It
Oil canning is a cosmetic issue commonly seen in metal panels, causing them to appear wavy or wrinkled. While it doesn’t affect the structural integrity of the roof or wall system, it is often an aesthetic concern for building owners. Several factors can contribute to oil canning, including the type of metal, how it is handled, and the installation process. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore what oil canning is, the causes behind it, and most importantly, how it can be minimized.
What Is Oil Canning?
Oil canning refers to the visible waviness or slight buckling in the flat areas of metal panels, particularly in standing seam metal roofs or wall systems. Though it may look concerning, it’s important to understand that oil canning is purely a cosmetic issue and does not compromise the structural integrity or functionality of the panels.
Key causes of oil canning include:
- Metal thickness
- Thermal expansion and contraction
- Handling and storage practices
- Installation and fastening techniques
- Building settlement
- Color and finish of the material
- Rollforming and slitting processes
Factors That Contribute to Oil Canning
Several variables play a role in oil canning. Understanding these factors can help you minimize the risk of this cosmetic defect in your roofing or wall systems.
1. Metal Thickness
Heavier-gauge metal panels are less prone to oil canning than lighter-gauge ones. The thicker the metal, the more resistant it is to warping under stress or environmental conditions. Therefore, one of the best ways to prevent oil canning is to use heavier-gauge panels.
Moreover, panels with striations or textured surfaces help reduce the likelihood of oil canning by breaking up the flat areas that are most susceptible. Some finishes, such as textured or matte coatings, can mask the appearance of oil canning, while glossier finishes may make it more noticeable. Similarly, lighter colors tend to hide oil canning better than darker shades, which can accentuate any slight imperfections.
2. Thermal Expansion and Contraction
Metal naturally expands when heated and contracts when cooled. When metal panels are “double-pinned” (fastened at both edges) without allowing for this natural movement, oil canning is more likely to occur. The stress from restricting thermal expansion causes the panels to warp slightly, leading to the wavy appearance commonly associated with oil canning.
Using floating clips or fasteners that allow for some panel movement can reduce this effect. Additionally, leaving enough space for panels to expand and contract can help minimize tension and prevent oil canning.
3. Handling & Storage
Improper handling and storage of metal coils and sheets before and after rollforming or slitting can lead to oil canning. Panels should be transported and stored in a way that minimizes stress, such as by ensuring they are fully supported and remain straight. Panels should be handled gently to avoid unnecessary bending or twisting.
When moving metal panels, ensure that they are supported every 10 to 12 feet and that they are carried perpendicular to the ground. Overhandling or rough transportation can lead to unwanted stress on the panels, contributing to oil canning. Following the manufacturer’s handling and storage instructions is key to reducing the risk of oil canning.
4. Installation & Fastening
Poor installation practices are one of the most common causes of oil canning. Two primary installation errors can contribute to oil canning:
- Over-driving fasteners: Tightening fasteners too much can place excessive stress on the panel’s edges, particularly in standing seam systems, which can distort the panel.
- Angling fasteners: Improperly angled fasteners can create uneven stress on the panel, leading to warping and, ultimately, oil canning.
To prevent this, it’s essential that fasteners be installed correctly, according to the manufacturer’s recommendations. Ensuring that the roof deck or wall structure is flat and even before installation is also critical in avoiding oil canning.
5. Settlement of the Structure
Oil canning may also be caused by structural settlement. As a building settles over time or experiences environmental changes, such as extreme weather, the structure may shift or distort. This movement can put pressure on the metal panels, causing them to bend or warp. Although this is less common than other factors, building movement should still be considered, particularly in areas prone to seismic activity or frequent storms.
6. Color and Finish of the Material
While all metal roofing and siding panels can experience oil canning, the color and finish of the material can influence how noticeable it is. Darker colors and glossy finishes tend to make oil canning more visible, as they reflect light more prominently. On the other hand, lighter colors and matte finishes can help to hide any minor waviness, making oil canning less apparent.
If you’re concerned about oil canning, opting for lighter-colored panels with textured finishes can significantly reduce its visibility. Discussing color options with your roofing contractor or metal supplier is essential in selecting the best material for your project.
7. Rollforming and Slitting Processes
The process of rollforming (shaping metal into panels) or slitting (cutting metal coils into smaller strips) can induce stress into the metal. This is due to the fact that metals have a memory and naturally try to return to their original shape. These internal stresses can result in oil canning, particularly if the metal is over-formed during these processes.
Working with experienced manufacturers who follow best practices for rollforming and slitting can help ensure that stress is minimized during production.
8. Other Stresses on the Panel
Additional stresses that can lead to oil canning include:
- Improper installation relative to the roof or wall dimensions.
- Out-of-tolerance roof decks that are not flat, including concave, convex, or uneven planes.
- Clips that are too tight or too loose on standing seam panels.
All of these factors can introduce stress into the panel, making it more likely to exhibit oil canning.
How to Minimize Oil Canning
While oil canning cannot be eliminated entirely, there are several ways to reduce its likelihood. By following best practices before, during, and after installation, contractors and homeowners can minimize the occurrence of oil canning.
Checklist for Minimizing Oil Canning:
-
Proper Storage: Ensure that panels are stored in a dry, supported, and protected area. Avoid any unusual twisting or stress on the materials.
-
Handling Practices: When handling panels, keep them horizontal and fully supported. Carry panels properly, supporting them every 10 to 12 feet to prevent excessive movement or bending.
-
Installation Preparation: Before installation, ensure that the roof deck or wall substrate is flat, even, and free of any warping. Bowing, whether concave or convex, can introduce stress into the metal panels.
-
Correct Installation: Follow the manufacturer’s installation guidelines carefully. Avoid over-driving or angling fasteners, and ensure that the panels have enough space to expand and contract.
-
Check for Flatness: Regularly inspect the panels during installation for signs of oil canning. This will allow you to make necessary adjustments before the entire roof or wall is completed.
-
Panel Movement: Make sure that the panels are properly aligned and moved carefully to the installation site. Observe for any signs of oil canning before fastening them to the roof deck or wall.
By being proactive and following these steps, contractors and homeowners can reduce the appearance of oil canning and ensure a smoother, more aesthetically pleasing installation.
Final Thoughts on Oil Canning
Oil canning is a common and natural occurrence in metal panels, particularly those used in roofing and siding applications. While it’s impossible to eliminate oil canning entirely, it can be minimized with proper handling, installation, and material selection.
It’s important to remember that oil canning is a cosmetic issue and does not compromise the structural integrity of the building. By understanding what causes oil canning and how to mitigate it, you can make informed decisions for your next metal roofing or siding project.
If you have any concerns about oil canning or would like more information on how to minimize its appearance, consult with your metal roofing contractor or supplier. Working with experienced professionals ensures that you get the best possible outcome for your project.
For more information or advice on metal roofing systems and oil canning, feel free to contact your local metal roofing specialist.